Sony Ericsson / Sony : General : can we depend on mobile revire " Eldar ' review?
>
New Topic
>
Reply<
Esato Forum Index
>
Sony Ericsson / Sony >
General
> can we depend on mobile revire " Eldar ' review?
Bookmark topic
we,
i read almost all of his reviews for all phones,
wat i noticed maybe for the last 2 years, nothing from SE is good to him??
ok , we know SE was doing so poorly lately, specially in the high-end fones,
but i thinnk for mid and low, they did good job..
for example the K770, its really good mid range all round fone.
still it did not got that much complemnt..
so , that wat i was thinking, so many fones in 2 years, nothing was good??
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 16:44:06
Edit :
Quote
Only if eldar does not express his personal issues on his particular reviews i will instead respect him more than i respect him before. his hands-own reviews isn't the best place to smoke out his emotionally loaded perceptions although the way he renders facts about the phones were neutral to me. so to sum it all, it's just that his mixing of facts and opinions were the things that annoyed me very often so he (imo) must sort it out and bring his grudges into dedicated forums instead and leave his review as clean as it can be
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 16:54:59
Edit :
Quote
lolol at fanboy-isms.
you need a phone? it's best to read around, google is the most baby-ish exercise for this. get a general consensus, read some specs & reviews.
stop believing in false gods & make up your own mind. it's just a phone FFS!!
(i have no idea who this person is & mean no offense to them)
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 17:47:51
Edit :
Quote
sorry, off topic. does Moscow get HSDPA coverage? thanks.
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 17:51:00
Edit :
Quote
Off-topic reply
:
Afaik Moscow doesn't have 3G, when the coverage maps of the GSM Association are up-to-date :
http://www.gsmworld.com/roaming/gsminfo/cou_ru.shtml
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 18:25:51
Edit :
Quote
me to critize Eldar comment on SE but one thing
he is around as long as ESATO...I think i first come across his site in 2002 or 2003
honestly same time as i know there's this forum call ESATO while the member on ESATO is small..... so the comment that he keep on attack SE product is not true.
but one thing i dislike is.... and I hope he got proof is on W595 keypad crack??? If he haven't crack one like we all experienced on W580 then he should not put the title of same problem etc etc...i hope i got him wrong but honestly if many other site comment the plastic quality is good...why only he comment it is no good.
yes SE latest platform is not tht good but i think he gone too far in commenting.... comon....i get so upset on Samsung F330 and Nokia N76 plastic quality...those are total rubbish...within 2 days got scratch or the chrome layer is coming off... those are poor quality. I never experience bad quality yet on SE product and I use SE or Ericsson product long enough to say it.....tht is the section which make me really dislike his review now.
especially if he is not a mechanical engineer.....I have no comment about his point of view for software......
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 18:34:51
Edit :
Quote
On 2008-08-02 16:38:08, X-Ter wrote:
Its my favourite mobile phone site but lately I'm beginning to get annoyed by Eldar. I don't mind him saying a few negative things about SE but at the moment he has nothing positive to say. The phones they are releasing are not as bad as he makes them out to be. I completely disagree with him about the W302 for example.
Also he cannot say anything wrong about Nokia. True, a few years ago he wasn't saying anything wrong about SE but he wasn't exactly attacking Nokia the way he is attacking SE right now. He needs to realise that a lot of people take him seriously and he is very influential so he really needs to become unbiased again.
_________________
[ This Message was edited by: X-Ter on 2008-08-02 15:38 ]
I'm one of the biggest SE fanboys and I have nothing positive to say about SE atm. Eldar's probably a bigger one than myself and that's what all the tough loving is for, at least someone SE's directly listening to is representing us on our disappointments. Just let him do his work on keeping SE on their toes, we should be cheering instead of bashing the guy. Let him influence those people into not buying SE (which I'm powerless of doing), affect their sales and give them their wake up call-again!
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 19:11:13
Edit :
Quote
i dont read eldar's reviews anymore, if he is getting bias to his reviews then he has a problem.. he should stop giving reviews if thats the case.
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 19:34:12
Edit :
Quote
Eldar definitely did not attack SE all along, and his reviews are still dependable. Probably the least biased reviews you will find. He just calls it like he sees it. In the past, he was always praising SE for their innovation. Now he feels like they are lacking that aspect. That's what I gathered from this quote from his W902 review:
"P.S. If some of you think that I’m being harsh in this write-up – you are spot on. I just can’t stand what they have done to one of the market’s finest line-up in no time after 5 years of development and hard work. They had a wake-up call back in 2007. Apparently, they didn’t hear it."
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 21:44:37
Edit :
Quote
naveedaziz83 Posts: > 500
anger and hate for SE have consumed him .. he is an agent of the dark side ...
and the force is strong with him ...
hehe just kidding .. sorry for being off-topic
--
Posted: 2008-08-02 22:22:27
Edit :
Quote
New Topic
Reply
