>
New Topic
>
Reply<
Esato Forum Index
>
Sony Ericsson / Sony >
General
> Ericsson T610 or Nokia 7250i ???
Bookmark topic
I would choose the T610, but if you want a phone that you actually here the ringingtones get the 7250i.
Ok that phone hasn't as good polyphonic sound but the T610 is not hearable
I always answer cause I feel the vibrator, maybe 40% of everytime I here the ringingtone.
Otherwise the T610 is better!!!
--
Posted: 2003-08-12 09:14:16
Edit :
Quote
Depends on what u want it to do
Nokia 72501:
+ better menu oriented, simple
+ bigger memory
+ xhtml
+ radio
- Cant send pics by IR, only by mms.
- no bluetooth
SE T610:
+ Bluetooth
+ better screen color
+ looks cool
- small memory
- hissing problems (old version)
- polyphonic sucks big time
- metal cover (have to clean it all the time)
If I were u, I keep my T68i and buy the 7250i as a second phone.
--
Posted: 2003-08-12 09:47:13
Edit :
Quote
Quote:
On 2003-08-12 09:47:13, masquerade71id wrote:
Depends on what u want it to do
Nokia 72501:
+ better menu oriented, simple
+ bigger memory
+ xhtml
+ radio
- Cant send pics by IR, only by mms.
- no bluetooth
SE T610:
+ Bluetooth
+ better screen color
+ looks cool
- small memory
- hissing problems (old version)
- polyphonic sucks big time
- metal cover (have to clean it all the time)
If I were u, I keep my T68i and buy the 7250i as a second phone.
7250i better menu!??!?!?!?!? hehe.. All nokia does not even compare to T610 menus!!
And the T610 can xhtml
So actually the 7250i is like this:
- worse menu oriented
+ bigger memory
+ radio
- Cant send pics by IR, only by mms.
- no bluetooth
+ polyphonic ringingtones are higher
- Plastic feel
+ Speaker phone
And for T610:
+ Bluetooth
+ better screen color
+ looks cool
+ Theme can be changed not only colors also pictures
- small memory
(- polyphonic sucks big time)
+ polyphonic sound even better than my computer
but isn't hearable!
(- metal cover (have to clean it all the time))
+ Metalcover, looks more expensive, feels like quality
+ IR sync, IR file sending/recieving
- No speaker phone
--
Posted: 2003-08-12 10:07:26
Edit :
Quote
I've used both phones for over a week now trying to decide which one I want as I WAS finding it difficult to decide.
Design
The keypad feels great on the 7250i and is nicer to use than the t610, however this comprimises the size of the screen. The t610 is slightly cramped to accomodate a much larger screen.
Having said this the Nokia with its smaller screen is slightly longer in lenghth. They are about the same size in width and the t610 is thinner.
Display
If you like customising your phone you can change loads of display settings on the t610 including themes. On the 7250i you can only change the colour of the cursor block so backgrounds will always be white in colour. Also the only other thing you can change is the wallpaper.
The colour display on the ericsson is much better than that of the 7250i. 65,596 colours compared to the Nokia's 4096 colours, this really shows in the picture quality, especially when using the camera.
Camera:
The picture quality on the 7250i is quite poor in compaison to all other camera phone models including the t610, panasonic gd87 etc. The t610 is MUCH BETTER. Also if you allocate a picture to a phone book entry when someone calls the picture takes up a large portion of the screen and is of a nice quality. On the Nokia its a fuzzy thumb nail and looks crap.
Ringtones:
The t610 has much better quality ringtones as they are 32 channel polyphonic, whereas the Nokia has only 4 channels. Most of the monophonic ringtones on the Nokia sound HORRIBLE as they are high pitched, and distort. Funny thing about the Nokia, and one that is very annoying is that the vibrator is louder than the actual ringtones and it does your head in after a while.
Txt messaging:
The Nokia wins when writing text messages as its very fast and very easy. The design of the keys really helps. The t610 isn't bad though, just slower.. if your a fast texter it won't be able to keep up with you. However I tried my boyfriends SE T610, which was one of the first ones with very old sw, and apparently the new ones are slightly faster.
Wap:
t610 has wap v2.0
7250i has wap version 1.2.1
Other features:
Nokia has timing profiles so a profile can switch its self off after a certain time and it also has a radio.
the t610 has an sms counter which I found very useful for keeping track of how many sms' your sending and it has bluetooth capabilities unlike the Nokia.
Both have infared.
Overall the t610 is packed with far more features and overall is better, and thats why I went for the T610. Hope this has helped.
[ This Message was edited by: anonymous1 on 2003-08-12 10:53 ]
--
Posted: 2003-08-12 11:51:45
Edit :
Quote
Go for the T610 man:D
--
Posted: 2003-08-12 14:36:05
Edit :
Quote
t610 of course,nokia got small resolution.only4096 cočours,only 16 channel polyphonic,no bluetooth,"half" ic,becouse she receiving just text via ic,dont send and record any sound,got stupid mms with only one pictures and one text,without polys.... only java(mophun is better,faster etc) got 4 mb memory,together with phonebook,messages,calendar,notes etc you cant store just pictures........sorry for my english is not my mom language,but i hope you understand me!!!greetings
--
Posted: 2003-08-12 15:09:35
Edit :
Quote
@ anonymous 1
Hmmm your a lady (havent noticed many on the forum) - very detailed/intelligent report, nice one - u forgot to mention the T610 is a sexy phone, im sure that swayed your decision also!!!
Ive already commented on this topic, if u do a search original poster (sorry forgot name) you'll find BonC's comments...
but ill say this quickly, having owned both phones -
viewing a picture I had taken on a 7250 on the actual phone made me wanna cry! - they were awful, the dot matrix screen and lack of colours made it so (however if transfered to PC they came up extremley well - in fact better than the T610pics on PC)
I sold the 7250 after a week
I still have the T610 for about 3 months now.
In my eyes a phone with an intergrated camera - had better make sure the camera is of decent quality or what the heck is the point.
Dont throw a substandard camera on as an after thought - BonC wont stand for it - LOL
--
Posted: 2003-08-12 18:38:01
Edit :
Quote
The main reason I bought T610 is I like it's look (exterior design) very much
--
Posted: 2003-08-12 19:45:31
Edit :
Quote
Hey BonC, although the picture quality on the 7250 is better once uploaded on to a PC I personally feel its more important to have the picture quality better on the phone for caller ID purposes and for having a general laugh as the primary purpose is to use the pics with the phone. In which case the 7250 pics look absolutely terrible when viewed on the phone. Put me right off.
--
Posted: 2003-08-13 00:11:06
Edit :
Quote
The ringtones on Nokias are generally pretty loud, and incredibly obtrusive!
I was on a train, and the guy next to me started ringing (Nokia 5100 I believe). It was
this (awful) tune, and sounded like some kid was whistling into my ear as hard as possible - very distorted and unpleasant.
But then again the 3650 was REALLY quiet when I tried it.
The T610 is pretty loud, but depends a lot on the midi files used.
[ This Message was edited by: kidscruff on 2003-08-13 00:57 ]
--
Posted: 2003-08-13 01:55:35
Edit :
Quote
New Topic
Reply
