News Forum Phone database

> New Topic
> Topic Locked
Esato Forum Index > Sony Ericsson / Sony > Symbian phones > P1i vs N95 Bookmark topic

lol dextrr!! u r a clown!!! what a waste!

n95 poor built quality that makes me sell it, a gap on the body is not tolerable, now you are comparing to p990 battery, which lasted may be less then a day, where if u use n95 only less than half a day, lol!!!

some people call it brain?
--
Posted: 2007-08-25 07:55:41
Edit : Quote




Thanks for your personal attack and after calling me a "clown" I didn't bother reading the rest of your post.

I really started to think this was a mature discussion forum. How wrong I am sometimes ... lol

Anyway back to topic now:

The P990 is SE's biggest failure! Just add a little bit more RAM and repackage it all nice and shiny, what do you get? The P1i! No way I'm paying $500 for 64mb extra ram!

Like I said before, we all complain about the N95's battery life. When SE can make something even close to the mind boggling specs of the N95 then you folks can compare them and argue about who's battery lasts longer. And now with the rumored 1200Mah N95 8gb battery, the N95 is even more of a "MUST BUY" for any tech addict!


--
Posted: 2007-08-25 09:48:12
Edit : Quote




rofl!!! u thought it was a mature discussion forum? rofl! now u r talking alrite, anyway, it's true and i have to agree with you, by all means p990i is quite a failure, in which se should be ashamed of, everyone is aware of it. but u can't blame a p990i battery for it lasts longer than a n95 in real life? and p990i was made by at least a better quality of materials that leaves no thin hair gap n etc. and that everyone knows that too

sure i'd like to get the n95 us or 8gb ver, provided it sorts out the built quality and battery life, at least to my usage. it will b a cracker!
--
Posted: 2007-08-25 10:49:55
Edit : Quote


[quote]
On 2007-08-24 18:05:47, mib1800 wrote:
tenshi888





Well I'm just recounting my experience. I have not checked recently but mine was really horrible NOTHING at all to compare to the build quality of the P990 much less the P1i. My P1i is built really well.





Then you are really lucky with your unit. There are no N95 users on the web that claim this same kind of battery life, makes me wonder what kind of real world usage you have i.e. talk time, music playing.




Do you actually own a P1i? Its much faster between shots, it takes a while to start up but once started you can keep the camera running in the background at all times as well. I will concede that the N95 took much better shots than the P1i.

I really, really hope that Nokia have improved their quality on the latest builds of the N95 but mine wasn't even that old. I had a 6300 loved it and thought Nokia had their act together, bought the N95 and was just horrified. I just don't wish it upon anyone else to make that mistake and I really hope to call Nokia out on such a shabby job on such an expensive phone. I don't get why anyone who has paid good money and made the same mistake would lead others to have the wrong impression about it. Build quality sucks, battery sucks, period.




[ This Message was edited by: tenshi888 on 2007-08-25 11:38 ]
--
Posted: 2007-08-25 12:27:51
Edit : Quote


@Dextrr

You really are a comedian the P990 has the honor of possibly being the most buggy phone ever released in the History of phones it's spec was up to date when announced but nearly a year later was well out of date when released. Your beloved P1 is nothing more than a P990 with an extra 64mb RAM you really are living in a fantasy world if you consider the P990 to be a quality product.

The N95 has a 332mhz processor and the full version of the graphics chip whilst the P990 and P1 have the light version hence no VGA video recording. I suggest you read the hundreds if not thousands of posts on this very Forum about all the problems people have suffered over the last year with their P990's before making such unsupportable statements. Also look at all the complaints in just a matter of weeks about the P1 also.

As for the battery on the P990 it didn't even ship with the battery it was announced to be shipped with and just now a year later this battery has arrived. The P990 has many more problems than just a lack of Ram it has badly written code and has followed over straight into the P1 i really do suggest you read all the complaints from users before making these absurd claims and calling a P990 class leading and ahead of it's time is just one of the funniest things i have read for ages. you clearly are delusional and out of touch with reality, no HSDPA, no Edge , No VGA video recording and the list goes on. The P990 was a great device when announced but quite simply it failed to deliver anything like what it promised and those are the opinions of people that bought one and feel severely cheated by SE.

You may not like the N95 and no says you have to either but to claim the P990 and P1 are more advanced makes you look ever so silly, think before you post and post based on facts not emotions as obviously like many others you love SE but SE have failed to treat their customers with respect hence stopping Firmware support for the P990 within year that only changed because they were forced to by the outcry and protest from their loyal supporters.


@Dragon Eye

Please show me anywhere i have stated that all N95's are perfect and without fault go on anywhere. The reason i mention how many have been sold and are still selling is to show as a % of units sold the amount with problems is small that is all. Yes you are completely right all products should be released with out fault and with perfect build quality and in an ideal world this is what should happen. Unfortunately we live in a far from ideal world. Again look at the relatively small numbers of P1's sold in this short time since launch and yet all the complaints that are already appearing all over this Forum covers coming off the keys, battery cover and other parts squeaking. cameras failing to work any longer, poor image quality, problems getting WiFi to work and it still exhibits some of the same bugs and problems as the P990 whose firmware this device is based on.

You are correct the N95 as all Symbian 9.1/9.2 devices do indeed suffer from some memory leaks the difference being the N95 starts with over 20mb of Ram and even with the leak remains at 19mb odd after closing programs. Compare that to the P990 that only starts with is 16 or 17mb and will fall all the way down to 7-8mb that's quite a difference you would have to agree. The only reason this is not of any importance in the P1 is SE added another 64mb to hide this problem but it's still there not cured is it?


Marc

_________________
Nokia E61, 2gb Sandisk, Fring, Shure EC2g


Honoured to have won BEST DEBATER


[ This Message was edited by: Dogmann on 2007-08-25 12:10 ]
--
Posted: 2007-08-25 12:36:24
Edit : Quote


Marc (as per usual) vastly overstates the problems relating to the P990i, and then (as per usual) underplays and makes excuses for, the appalling build quality and battery issues that affect the N95.
However if TS aint your bag, then the N95 is the better device IMO.
--
Posted: 2007-08-25 12:48:15
Edit : Quote


@Dogmann

You've missed the irony.

Dextrr neither owns a P1, nor is he praising the P990...

Re-read his post

--
Posted: 2007-08-25 12:51:52
Edit : Quote


You just make me laugh all the time Dogmann, keep it coming Nokia is NOT better then SE, and I have had a lot of nokia phones in my time. We will allways see you on internet when its time for Nokia vs SE, and for you ALL the Nokias phones are better then SE's phones. And dont try to say you have a different point of view, thats a fact for you. And this is just making me laugh all the time you are posting same thing all over again, again, again, again, and again.

You are just like an old record pointing the same things. This make me wonder if you can find something new to print, can you ?

As for the N95 vs P1i, the P1i is far better then the N95. And now I am not talking about the software side. You just cant compare the built quality between this to phones. The N95 has NO chance at all here

_________________


[ This Message was edited by: Tail on 2007-08-25 11:57 ]

[ This Message was edited by: Tail on 2007-08-25 12:00 ]
--
Posted: 2007-08-25 12:56:53
Edit : Quote


@myth

Quite possible as i can just about focus on the screen right now due to pain and meds, i am sinking into oblivion fast just taking the dog for a walk and then sleep.

@mweb6161

If you don't believe what i am saying just thread all the posts in this Forum as i am most certainly not over estimating the problems far from it. Again i haven't said here or any where else that the N95 is perfect either. But mine certainly didn't suffer from any of the problems mentioned and neither did my N93. Maybe I'm just lucky and always seem to get a good unit as believe me if i didn't you and every one else would hear all about it. As i wasn't happy with the sound qaulity on my E90 and reported such although i have now realised this was partially down to a rubbish 2.5m to 3.5m adapter i was using.

Any way for now i am sticking to my E61 and am not buying any more mobile devices until the true E61 successor arrives hopefully early next year. As the E61 is easily the best smart phone i have ever owned and used a simply superb device I have given up my Mobile device addiction and will not be buying any more devices any time soon.

Marc
--
Posted: 2007-08-25 13:07:43
Edit : Quote


Tail

The continuous harping on N95 wobbly slider which has been fixed eons ago - that's broken record playing. Continuous mis-information that N95 can only last 1/2 day on normal typical use - that's broken record playing.



Well, there has been numerous report that P1i camera konking out. Well, you are right. N95 has NO chance of having this bad quality.


[ This Message was edited by: mib1800 on 2007-08-25 12:14 ]
--
Posted: 2007-08-25 13:11:02
Edit : Quote

---

New Topic   Topic Locked

Forum Index