News Forum Phone database

> New Topic
> Reply
< Esato Forum Index > Sony Ericsson / Sony > General > help me choose my phone. k850i - w910i Bookmark topic



???????

¤ the speakers on w910 sounds bad...(just READ the w910 review here on Esato)...k850 speakers have loud & good sound.

¤the build quality is not better then k850, (im not saying its bad...but i can promise you that Sonyericsson have concentrate more on k850 then on w910..(k850 is their new flagship if you didnt know that...w910 is the little brother to w960)

and yes...k850 have also 3.0 (Megabass) + motion sensor.

if you looking for a hardcore phone.....wait for w960.
------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.esato.com/board/viewtopic.php?topic=157146
citat:

"The loudspeaker is absolutely terrible. It sounds like somebody left a pair of headphones on the desk and is playing music through them. Lacks volume AND clarity.

The shake function is a huge gimmick. You have to hold the Walkman button on the top of the handset whilst flicking from side to side, which contorts your hands in a weird manner. The volume up/down keys when held perform the same action with much less effort.

The keypad is disappointing too, it is like a shiny plastic version of a Razr, .........................

_________________
I k850i, w810i & T28


[ This Message was edited by: plankgatan on 2007-10-18 22:41 ]

[ This Message was edited by: plankgatan on 2007-10-18 22:41 ]
--
Posted: 2007-10-18 23:18:19
Edit : Quote




nop.......

the Loudspeaker in W910 MUCH louder than K850
here Chal from Howardforums buy both of them W910 and K850
and here what he said about that:

"Still playing with the phones but to answer your question, the speakerphone is MUCH louder on the w910i. Call quality and volume on both using the regular speaker is about the same. "

here is the link
http://www.howardforums.com/showthread.php?t=1259478&page=1&pp=15

and about the built quality W910 is much way better ..... and you have to know the battery cover in K850 Wobble and I think there is a thread about that here in esato forum
and this is about built quality by Chal:

"The build quality on the w910i is awesome. The k850i is good except the slot that opens up to insert battery, sim, and mem card feels fragile."

w910 is the flagship of walkman Java Phone
and you have to know W960 is a cheap looking Phone and it's didn't had a superb loudspeaker according to GSMarena and mobile-review

You don't have W910 so you cannot say K850 has walkman Player 3 on it!!
especially there is no sense me feature in K850 which is more important than Megabass

alongside that W910 boast 2.44 inch screen and K850 Only 2.2


--
Posted: 2007-10-18 23:39:56
Edit : Quote


""w910 is the flagship of walkman Java Phone
and you have to know W960 is a cheap looking Phone""

""the battery cover in K850 Wobble""

eehhhhh

havnt read so much rubbish before.....

try to convince someone else.....im not buying it.

_________________
I k850i, w810i & T28




[ This Message was edited by: plankgatan on 2007-10-18 22:47 ]
--
Posted: 2007-10-18 23:44:22
Edit : Quote


Have you had both phones before?
Or are you going based on what you've read?

Because "Chal" from howardforums has both phones..
I'd take his word over anyone else's unless you've had both as well..

Perhaps its hit and miss with each phone.
Its no mystery that some phones are lemons



[ This Message was edited by: draft on 2007-10-18 22:48 ]
--
Posted: 2007-10-18 23:47:45
Edit : Quote


Both phone have very nice future..
But I did choose W910 instant K850 .

Maybe I like slim phone more
--
Posted: 2007-10-18 23:48:21
Edit : Quote


i like w910 to..think its a beatiful phone...(so dont get me wrong)...but i dont agree that w960 is looking cheap and that w910 is the new flagship....... w960 will eat w910 like nothing.....its a much better/advanced phone.

for me the camera is important..thats why i choose k850....and because it have 3.0 + Megabass......

_________________
I k850i, w810i & T28

[ This Message was edited by: plankgatan on 2007-10-18 23:07 ]
--
Posted: 2007-10-19 00:03:37
Edit : Quote




My friend
I am not trying to convince you or someone else
I just want to tell you the fact that said
W910 is better than K850 in EVERYTHING except the camera
and K850 better than W910 ONLY by the camera

[ This Message was edited by: Pop Lover on 2007-10-18 23:06 ]
--
Posted: 2007-10-19 00:05:04
Edit : Quote



so now you hava a quick review by chal there who has both phones and kits who had a few nokias before and got a w910 so its wasnt a biased review:) you can take both there words
im happy with what they say and so you should be too pop lover, and anyone else who juggling to get the w910

@plankgatan

its the flagship of walkman java phones
it sucks that the battery cover wobbles but i dont think thats much of a flaw

w960 cheap looking :s umm doesnt look cheap looking to me and thats
the flagship Symbian phone
thats how im seeing it

i dont think he was tryin to convince you to buy it making an statement not to diss the w910
thats all


EDIT:
HAHAH we posted at the same time pop lover
_________________
aKa Chiller


[ This Message was edited by: DarkKrypt on 2007-10-18 23:08 ]

[ This Message was edited by: laffen on 2007-10-20 19:58 ]
--
Posted: 2007-10-19 00:06:50
Edit : Quote


Plankgatan ,

Could for GOD sake stop all the time PRAISING your K850 , man you have to admit it , W910 does have a better Build quality then K850 , you seem to be saying that K850 is better in everything.Ok, I beilive K850 boasts a 5MP Camera , So it will definately take better pictures , thats obvious.So why can't you just admit that W910 does have a better built quality then K850 ?

Regarding the sound , i compared my K750 with a K850 , and TBH the K850 was SLIGHTLY louder then K750 ...
I haven't listened to the W910's speakers myself , so i can't say whether they are better then K850 or not , But from what ive HEARD , W910 does have better speakers then K850 ...

And i think someone here also said that K850 takes pictures like K800 , that is totally not true , K850 has a 5 MP and it will and has taken better pictures than K800 ...

One more thing you have to admit , your the ONLY member on ESATO who says that the K850 is fast and it doesn't get stuck sometimes , and whatever ... All the other people have said that K850 does get Stuck sometimes , And i haven't heard anyone yet complaining that W910 stucks/hangs ... So you gotta also beilive this fact that W910 is faster then K850 ...


So the explaination to all this is ,

W910 is a better phone overall , but its camera is weak.
K850 wins over the camera , because it boasts a 5MP Camera ...


EDIT : Hey Darkkrypt and Pop Lover , it seems i was writing my post while you guys already posted
_________________
I love my K750 !
I love my N73 Music Edition !
I love my Sony Ericsson K810 !

[ This Message was edited by: rockerZ on 2007-10-18 23:11 ]
--
Posted: 2007-10-19 00:09:39
Edit : Quote


Ok, so just to clear things up, the w910 AS OF NOW is the walkman flagship.

However comparing the w960 with the w910 is questionable.
The w960 boasts alot of things the w910 doesnt have, along with the fact its running a different UI which classifies it as a smartphone..

Take away the wifi, autofocus and different UI of the w960 and you have what?
A walkman phone in candybar form as opposed to slider..

And all this debating and arguing and "praising" of the k850 is useless..
Its not a question of which phone is better.

Its all a matter of which phone suits the users needs.
If you listen to music alot, then the w910 is for you.
If you love taking pictures, then sure, get the k850

You guys make it more complicated than it actually is

But just fyi, I've talked to a major supplier here locally, and even he said he prefers the w910 over the k850 and 6500 slide by nokia.. just based on usability and functions

[ This Message was edited by: draft on 2007-10-18 23:20 ]
--
Posted: 2007-10-19 00:18:26
Edit : Quote

---

New Topic   Reply

Forum Index